Thursday, May 20, 2010

Chrummboew

My one problem with Trumbo's assertion in that soldiers can only fight for a cause that is their own and not an ideal is the lack of unity within an army if all the things the soldiers are fighting for are separate. The purpose of fighting for an ideal, or at least to the higher-ups in an army, is to unite all the soldiers behind this idea. This makes these soldiers a much more cohesive unit with more drive to fight, eventually making the whole army more powerful. However, where Trumbo is right is that some people will not believe in the ideal in the first place, and this is where the situation gets tricky. Creating a draft, although sometimes necessary, causes problems in the way of camaraderie and the inner drive of soldiers, so such a practice should be avoided until circumstances call for its definite necessity.

3 comments:

Chris Thompson said...

This is a well worded blog, i agree with you position that there are things worth fighting for. The draft defiantly does have it's problems it takes people who do not believe in a cause and makes them fight for it. Though the belief that people should not die for freedom that they will never have is selfish, it our forefathers had acted thus america would have ceased to exist.

Marcus van der Meulen said...

Brian, thank you for being the one person that realizes that Trumbo's thoughts on war just don't really work, that when you have an army full of individuals, it's not an army. I really enjoy your astute counter to Trumbo's ideals and I find it rather refreshing. 6 stars out of 5 for breaking the mold, excellent blog!

Unknown said...
This comment has been removed by the author.